Breaking Barriers: The formation and expression of a female identity

My exhibition explores themes of female identity through the lens of the life and work of Pan Yuliang and other female Chinese artists.

In the early 20th century, China was experiencing radical social and political turmoil. This upheaval ushered in a change in women’s roles in society and the opportunities afforded to them. As a result of what is referred to as the 1919 May Fourth Movement, education for women became more attainable as, for the first time, co-education was allowed (Teo 2016, 39-41). With greater opportunities for women, came an increased awareness of their rights and social roles, now less restricted by traditional Chinese ethics (Li 2000, 31). Along with more freedom, women sought new ways to express themselves and discover an identity outside of being a mother, daughter, or wife.

Pan Yuliang was born in 1895, orphaned at a young age, she was considered a piece of property. She was sold and bought, eventually marrying Customs Official, Pan Zanhua as his concubine at only 18 (Andrews 1998, 178). Suddenly married to an official, her social status changed dramatically which afforded her the opportunity to pursue her talent for art. Pan grabbed the chance to go to the Shanghai Art Academy when education became co-ed for the first time in 1919 (Teo 2016, 41). She then traveled to Europe in 1921 on fine arts government scholarship as one of the first of the Chinese students to study art in France where she eventually made her home. It was rare at the time for women to achieve independent careers as professional artists (Ng 2019, 21-31). Pan Yuliang was a pioneer as both an artist and a woman. 

Pan painted thousands of paintings throughout her life in a wide variety of styles. Pan’s art reflects both her western training as well as her Chinese heritage, with some paintings in brilliant, vivid, fauvist styles and others in the more traditional ink on paper Chinese styles (Ng 2019, 21-31). The majority of her work, however, combines these two aspects of her life, both in technique and subject matter. Said subject matter is the most striking and revolutionary aspect of Pan’s work. The one uniting theme throughout all of her art is women. Pan painted women of all different backgrounds in various aspects of life. Over half of her paintings were non-white female nudes (Teo 2016, 57), embracing all flaws and imperfections in, not only the female body, but also their lives. Pan’s art is a rebellion against the commodification of the female body and an expression of a female identity. From her nudes to her self portraits, Pan strove to represent women openly and without shame.

Pan Yuliang, Artist Self-Portrait, 1963. Oil on Canvas, 80 x 65 cm. (Source: Teo 2016, 34)

Works cited:

Andrews, Julia Frances, and Kuiyi Shen. “The Lure of the West: Modern Chinese Oil Painting.” In A Century in Crisis: Modernity and Tradition in the Art of Twentieth-Century China. Guggenheim Museum Publications, 1998. 172-78.

Li, Yuhui. “Women’s movement and change of women’s status in China.” Journal of International Women’s Studies 1, no. 1 (2000): 30-40.

Ng, Sandy. “The Art of Pan Yuliang: Fashioning the Self in Modern China.” Woman’s Art Journal 40, no. 1 (2019): 21–31.

Teo, Phyllis. “Pan Yuliang: The Misunderstood ‘Mistress’ of Western Painting.” In Rewriting modernsim. Three women artists in twentieth-century China: Pan Yuliang, Nie Ou and Yin Xiuzhen. Leiden University Press (LUP): Leiden, 2016.

Informative Webpage – Pan Yuliang

As, arguably the most well known female artist from 20th Century China, it is no surprise that Pan Yuliang is the only one of the artists I am studying that has an entire website dedicated to her. The website panyulin.org is extremely well rounded and includes everything from her biography to every newspaper article about her. It also includes a complete collection of every one of her works categorized by material and subject. Although the site is primarily in Chinese, it does have an English option to make it more accessible.  It can be very difficult to find information about many female artists of this time because their lives and works were so poorly documented so this website is very helpful as it is so thorough and accessible.

https://www.panyulin.org/index.php

Pan Yuliang (Self Portrait) – Visual Analysis

Pan Yulaing – Self Portrait (1945), Oil on canvas, 73.5 x 60 cm

Source: A Century in Crisis, page 169 (figure 69)

Pan Yulaing (1895-1977) is best known for her female nude paintings but I decided to focus on one of her self portraits for my visual analysis as I feel they best embody the spirit of my topic. Pan Yulaing painted many self-portraits over the course of her life, giving us a better glimpse into her life, each one a reflection of her self-preception. The painting I chose, Self Portrait (1945), was painted by Pan Yulaing in Paris a few years after she moved back to Europe for good (Andrews and Shen 1998: 178). Painting in the western style of oil on canvas, Pan uses a mix of post-impressionist styles with hints of fauvism influence, reflecting her western training, although the colors she uses in this painting are darker and more serious (Andrews and Shen 1998: 178)

In this painting, Self Portrait (1945), Pan Yuliang depicts herself standing in front of a closed window confidently leaning one hand against a table with a vase of yellow flowers. Unlike many of her other self-portraits where Pan depicts herself dressed in traditional Chinese garb, in this portrait she is wearing her hair up while dressed in simple western-style clothing, showing her struggle with her Chinese identity. Her bright, rosy cheeks and pink lips are contrasted by bulky winter clothes that hide her feminine figure with dark, traditionally non-feminine, colors and patterns. 

Pan’s facial expression is serious and confident, portraying an air of professionalism. In opposition to social customs which dictated that women must avert their gaze as a show of modesty (Ng 2019: 26), Pan Yuliang stares straight ahead with a penetrating and unflinchingly direct gaze, challenging the preconceived notions of how women should act. The yellow blossoms behind her are reminiscent of classic feminine ideals and the vase suggestive of the outdated views of women she was forced to fight against her whole life. In traditional Chinese culture, women were often compared to flower vases, equating them to a fragile decorative object with no substance (Ng 2019: 25). By juxtaposing herself next to the vase of flowers (a reoccurring theme in many of her self-portraits) she confronts these antiquated and oppressive ideas, challenging viewers with her piercing gaze. She paints herself as a complex human being rather than as a clichéd ornamental beauty that women were so often portrayed as in art.

Works Cited:

Andrews, Julia Frances, and Kuiyi Shen. A Century in Crisis: Modernity and Tradition in the Art of Twentieth-Century China. Guggenheim Museum Publications, 1998.

Ng, Sandy. “The Art of Pan Yuliang: Fashioning the Self in Modern China.” Woman’s Art Journal 40, no. 1 (2019): 21–31.

Artist Biography – Guan Zilan

Born in Shanghai, China in 1903, Guan Zilan became one of the most famous female artists in China in the 20th century. She was exposed to the world of art at a young age through her parents who were wealthy textile merchants. Guan went to school at the Shanghai Shenzhou Girls’ School before attending the China Art University where she studied western painting under the famous artist, Chen Baoyi. After graduating in 1927, Guan Zilan further pursued painting in Japan at the Tokyo Institute of Culture: Bunka Gakuin. It was in Japan that Guan was greatly influenced by western modern art, especially post-impressionism and, more notably, fauvism and in 1929, at the age of 26, Guan Zilan painted her most famous work, Portrait of Miss L. (shown below). As a female artist trained in western styles –a rare sight at the time– Guan became very popular in both Japan and China and was regarded as an embodiment of the “modern girl.” After her return to China in 1930, Guan became a professor at a Shanghai art college, where she continued to be very popular and was a leader among female artists until the start of the Cultural Revolution when she stopped painting.

Guan Zilan – Portrait of Miss L. Oil on Canvas. 1929.

Source: A Century in Crisis, Page 63 (Figure 62).

 

Works Referenced:

Andrews, Julia Frances., and Kuiyi Shen. “Art in the New Culture of the 1920s.” The Art of Modern China. Berkeley: U of California, 2012. 70-71.

Andrews, Julia Frances, and Kuiyi Shen. “The Lure of the West: Modern Chinese Oil Painting.” In A Century in Crisis: Modernity and Tradition in the Art of Twentieth-Century China. Guggenheim Museum Publications, 1998. 172-78.

Lü Peng. A History of Art in 20th Century China. Milano: Charta, 2010. 286-8.

Pickowicz, Paul G., Kuiyi Shen, and Yingjin Zhang. Liangyou: Kaleidoscopic Modernity and the Shanghai Global Metropolis, 1926-1945. Leiden: Brill, 2013. 206-29.

Introduction – Emily Caruso

Hi everyone! My name is Emily Caruso and I’m a junior and Environmental Geoscience major. I am currently home in Acton, Massachusetts with my family. I am the middle child of three girls so being home with both of my sisters again has definitely been an adventure but my dog sure is loving all the extra attention. I have mostly taken science classes here at Union so I don’t have much experience in this subject but I love art and I have always been interested in Chinese culture so this class definitely sparked my interest and I am excited to learn!